3 Shocking Reasons You Can’t Count On A Background Check

Feb 4, 2019 | Hiring Help, Safety Smart, Safety Tips

It’s one of the first things people think of when they want to feel safe: “I should run a background check.”

So more and more sites are making them part of their promise to keep you safer… whether you’re hiring a babysitter, finding someone to walk your dog while you’re at work, looking for a handyman, or even renting a house.

But there’s a lot more to background checks than you may know…. and that peace of mind? Well, the next time you see a user online who boasts that they’ve passed a background check, keep digging.


We learned why from an unusual source from the most powerful city in the world…


Did you know that each day in Washington, D.C., dozens of people arrive at the White House asking to see the president? They just “pop in.” In that moment, the Secret Service has about 3 seconds to decide whether or not that person is a threat. (Usually, they’re just a bit delusional.)

SafetyPIN founder Jenny Thompson discovered that when she was talking with the former White House Chief of Security and SafetyPIN Security Expert John Gill. At the time, Jenny was beginning to develop what has become the new standard in personal safety, SafetyPIN’s Trust Badge. It was just after a dangerous close encounter with a dog sitter she hired on Craigslist.

But that’s not all she discovered. As she began to build SafetyPIN, Jenny found three huge flaws in traditional background checks that may shock you.

Any one of these facts alone is enough to “trick” you into bringing someone dangerous into your home and around your family, even if they passed a criminal background check.

So when you’re using an app that promises that their users are background checked – whether or not it is mandatory – take caution. Because it doesn’t mean what we think it does.


Here are 3 shocking secrets about background checks:


1) There is no such thing as a national background check

Many people think that “national” background checks scan any offense committed anywhere in the U.S. But actually, only 16 states report 100% of criminal activity up to databases (keep reading for more on the lack of publicly available data). Even more shocking is the fact that 22 states do NOT automatically report any criminal data to those same databases. And in the rest of the states, some counties report, and some don’t.

2) Standard background checks stop checking at the county line

Other than the national sex offender registry, the state sex offender registries, and federal charges (like drug trafficking and identity theft) , almost all criminal activity is recorded at the county level. So when a background check promises to go to the county level, that means you probably won’t get any history for the county next door. For some perspective, this means that if someone lives in New York City, and you run a standard background check on them, you wouldn’t know if they had one of the following non-federal charges 1 mile away in Brooklyn, because it’s a different county:

Driving intoxicated
Battery or Assault
… and more!

3) Approximately 40% of Crimes in the U.S. Go Unreported

That means, for every 100 crimes committed in the United States, 40 are never even reported to police. And since background checks can only tell you what people have been arrested and tried for, a large number of crimes are completely unavailable. That is a huge limitation. I mean, how can background checks protect you if they can’t piece together the full story of someone’s past? They can’t.


But there is a solution…


SafetyPIN was created to overcome these three flaws. Our screening process goes further and deeper into an applicant’s history and behavior than any background check. Like we said above, most background checks stop at the county line, but we know most criminals don’t. That’s why we’ve worked with a federal investigator to audit all 3,200 counties in the U.S. and tell us where we could get digitally-available data and where we couldn’t. Then we work with independent vendors to drill down on the information we need, never stopping until we have the best combination of data to fill gaps in someone’s record – even if it means sending someone to a small town courthouse to get a photocopy of someone’ record.

But since 40% of crimes are never reported anywhere, we didn’t stop there. Our team has worked with an expert team of criminal profilers that includes a forensic psychologist to develop the specialized questions and scoring in our behavioral review. The results of our behavioral review allow us to identify red flags, even if the person has no criminal history.

If someone has displayed their SafetyPIN on their profile, they’re letting you know they care about your safety and they can be trusted in real life. Whether it’s a babysitter, handyman, dog walker, or house cleaner, always make sure to ask for their SafetyPIN before you let anyone in your home or around your family…or meet them anywhere offline.

You don’t have to rely on flawed sources of data or hoping for the best. Start creating connections based on trust with a SafetyPIN. You can apply for one (or ask someone else to) for just $1 here.

Be sure to check out our video with more information below:

Additional Posts

Babysitting on the side? Earn DOUBLE when you make this one change to your profile.

Sitters with a SafetyPIN badge reported an average of 17.9 jobs, versus sitters not using a SafetyPIN badge reported 8.4 jobs, over the same period of time. The average amount earned across the board for all sitters was $74 per job. In other words, parents booked SafetyPIN sitters TWICE as often as non-SafetyPIN sitters. Learn More.

But is SafetyPIN fair?

"Isn’t SafetyPIN just one more way to discriminate against people?" We get asked that question...a lot. Following George Floyd's death and the spotlight it put on criminal justice in the US, we hear it even more. And we understand why. Black, brown, and lower-income...

Safety Matters: Looking for a nanny or babysitter?

  Before choosing a babysitting app, make sure you know what “background checked” really means?   In this article: Surprising facts about background checks – and why they don’t always mean what you think App-by-app comparison of trust and safety standards...