Four Reasons Hiring a College Student to Babysit Might be Your Smartest Choice

Job Hunting, Safety Smart, Tips and Tricks

Need a sitter?

Why not hire someone… 

  • Whose pay can be a tax-deduction for you both
  • Who is mature enough to be responsible yet is still playful with your kids
  • Whose schedule is flexible and can accommodate your non-traditional work hours
  • Who is easy to trust…when they have a SafetyPIN? 

All of this is possible when you hire a college student! Whether you need an after-school nanny, a date-night sitter, are required to work overtime or travel or need an occasional daytime caregiver so you can break away for a few hours, hiring a college student is a smart option.

College students make great babysitters for lots of reasons. But here are four game-changers:

  1.   College Nannies and sitters are tax-advantaged employees.

Lucky for you, lucky for them: college caregivers are tax-advantaged employees! This means that a portion of what you pay your college sitter is a tax deduction for both of you. This is how it works: a family can reimburse a college student up to $5,250 for tuition, books, and fees/supplies, and have the entire contribution considered non-taxable. Of course, this can’t be a replacement for all the student’s wages, which by law must be at least minimum wage. But by structuring your payroll to capitalize on this strategy, both you and your new sitter will come out ahead. Want to learn more? Check this out.

  1.   College students are old enough to be responsible, but young enough to be fun.

Beyond the tax advantages, college students are mature, make great mentors, and are highly motivated. They are also a lot of fun. In addition, many demonstrate the type of mastery in their babysitting skills that can only come from experience.

  •  Mature: College students are more experienced and mature than the average neighborhood teenager. They are young adults, eager to prove themselves.
  • Mentors: Most college students are goal-oriented and have a good head on their shoulders. They make great mentors for your kids. Joe Keely, who founded College Nannies+Sitters+Tutors in 2001, says

“When I was still a college student, I took a summer job as a nanny for three children. I quickly learned that I loved my job—and that it was because I was more than a babysitter: I was tested every day to be a positive role model for these kids …”

  • Motivated: Almost all of them need extra income, but their class schedules make holding down a regular job in retail or even fast-food nearly impossible. In the words of Rutgers college student Riley Dixon, babysitting for a family was “definitely better than any other job I held in college.” 
  • Mastery: Many college students earned their babysitting stripes under the careful eye of their local communities, their churches, and of course, their parents. By the time they are college students, they are masters at the craft, some with as many as five years of experience in babysitting before they arrive at your door.
  1. College students have a flexible schedule that can often accommodate your non-traditional work hours

There are a lot of reasons why your needs for childcare may not match the hours of standard daycare centers or relatives and friends. Maybe you work at a job that requires weekends or evenings — or have to work rotating shifts. Perhaps you travel or are expected to assist with after-hours events. What can you do with your children when these “after-hours” demands arise and your regular sitter can’t make it? 

A college student could be your best choice. College students often stack their classes in the mornings or on certain days of the week, leaving themselves completely free on their non-class days, afternoons or evenings. 

If you have the type of job that requires flexible hours, or if you work two jobs, a very smart option would be to cultivate a long-term babysitting relationship with a couple of college students who can schedule their classes to be free during the hours that you need them most.

  1. Look for a sitter with a SafetyPIN.

What is SafetyPIN? It’s like a background check on steroids — with two shots of espresso. 

After all, how can you really know who’s coming to your home or caring for your kids when you’re choosing someone new? Recommendations are great. But what about when you have to try someone new? Some sites offer their own background checks, but they are incomplete and only cover convictions. And who knows when they were last updated?!

That’s where SafetyPIN™ comes in… as the only fast track to trust.

SafetyPIN includes a broader, more expansive criminal background check, an ID verification, a financial history screening, and our proprietary Beacon Behavioral Review. That lets us eliminate people that set off red flags, even if their criminal record doesn’t show anything.

Anyone 18 years and older can apply for a SafetyPIN for only $1. When someone is approved for a SafetyPIN, they are given a trust badge that can be shared on any profile they choose. It means they passed our strict screening requirements, designed by a team of security experts with over 80 years of experience in law enforcement and criminal profiling. You can verify SafetyPINs quickly and easily, so you can know if someone you met online is safe to meet and interview in real life. Our goal is to help you feel more secure when you take an online transaction offline. Or, as we like to say… keeping you safer from URL to IRL. For more on why you should ask your next sitter for a SafetyPIN, check out this two-minute video.

Additional Posts

Babysitting on the side? Earn DOUBLE when you make this one change to your profile.

Sitters with a SafetyPIN badge reported an average of 17.9 jobs, versus sitters not using a SafetyPIN badge reported 8.4 jobs, over the same period of time. The average amount earned across the board for all sitters was $74 per job. In other words, parents booked SafetyPIN sitters TWICE as often as non-SafetyPIN sitters. Learn More.

But is SafetyPIN fair?

"Isn’t SafetyPIN just one more way to discriminate against people?" We get asked that question...a lot. Following George Floyd's death and the spotlight it put on criminal justice in the US, we hear it even more. And we understand why. Black, brown, and lower-income...

Safety Matters: Looking for a nanny or babysitter?

  Before choosing a babysitting app, make sure you know what “background checked” really means?   In this article: Surprising facts about background checks – and why they don’t always mean what you think App-by-app comparison of trust and safety standards...